Jumat, 04 Januari 2008

THE MOST POPULAR NEWS PORTAL IN INDONESIA

By Akhmad Kusaeni

Indonesian press goes online since 1995[1]. Some of print media, newspapers and news magazines, put their stories on the web. Republika Daily (http://republika.co.id) and Kompas Daily (http://kompas.com) were amongst the pioneer to go online. Then, others newspapers follow to use web as medium of their publication.
But, Republika and Kompas were not practice online journalism at the beginning. What public read on the websites was almost the same thing that appeared in print edition. So, basically, kompas.com and republika.co.id were still in tradition of print media, not online media.
Then, on 1997, Budiono Darsono and Abdul Rachman, two veterans Indonesian journalist, set up Detik.com (http://www.detik.com) as the real first online newspaper in Indonesia[2]. Detik.com is not only doesn’t have print edition, but also designed for Internet users. Detik is Indonesian word for “second” and provides continuously updated news, hopefully every second.
“It is updated all the times. When important stories occurs, at the same time occurs in the web. There is editorial policy that reporters should report breaking news not more than 10 minutes after it happen. Sometimes we publish stories as it happens,” said Danang Sangga Buwana, Detik.com senior editor[3].
In my opinion, one of the key successes of Detik.com is political transition in Indonesia. A year before President Soeharto falls down on May 1998, political climate in the country was on the rise. Mass demonstrations, ethnic and religious violence and riots were almost happened every time and everywhere. Rumors on military coup were spreading anytime.
Because of government tight control on print and broadcast media, this kind of “hot stories” didn’t appear in mainstream newspapers, radios or televisions. And, people found it at online media, especially on Detik.com. This news portal has become alternative information for Indonesian people during crucial time at the end of New Order corrupt regime.
It was also a proof of diminishing control of New Order government to control flow of information. Soeharto regime could disband publication of newspapers or shut down television stations, but it couldn’t censor or shut down online media. It was not only because we don’t have cyber law yet, but also because too hard to control cyber space.
Detik.com, then, instantly became a runaway success, becoming the most popular news source in Indonesia. Detik.com’s page views rate leaped from 3,000 per day in July 1998, to 735,000 per day by October 2000. Hit rates have also leaped from 15,000 per day to 4,3 million per day.[4]
Although Detik.com have achieved successes financially and credibility, others Indonesian news portal (we have at least 10 news websites) are not lucky enough even just to survive. One of news portal that has becoming dinosaurs was Indonesiakini.com (http://www.Indonesiakini.com). Trying to follow the success of Malaysiakini.com (http://www.malaysiakini.com), this news portal simply couldn’t survive because the lack of funding from investors. It was formally set up on April 1999, and on September 2000 Indonesiakini.com was formally closed down itself.[5]
It was not because of police raid its office or government shut down and arrested its reporters, but it was simply the investors didn’t have more money to fund sustainability their publication. Indonesiakini.com premature death was not political matters, but obviously money matters.
The collapse of some Indonesian news portal was also due to inability of the management and editorial board to present accurate and timely news and stories. Because it is online, it doesn’t mean news portal may abandon principles of good journalism. Because it is cyber world, it doesn’t mean we are free to spread rumors, gossips, and half truth in media online. Because it is uncensored and untouchable by government control, it doesn’t mean we are free to attack anybody or do character assassination to the leaders, politicians or celebrities.
The booming of online media, of course, helps democratization and freedom of the press in Indonesia. Online media enriches public sphere by providing alternative sources of information. It breaks down monopoly of truth by government or mainstream media.
Indonesia doesn’t have regulation to guard freedom of the press in Internet. We don’t have cyber law yet. But, it doesn’t mean that law cannot reach cyber world. According to Brata Mandala, officer at Information Technology of Indonesian Police Headquarters, police might use Indonesian Criminal Code (KUHP) to deal with cyber crime. [6]
For example, article 335 KUHP is sufficient enough to use for defamation and libel posted in websites. Even if, the host of websites living abroad, Indonesian police will do coordination with International Police (Interpol), FBI or CIA to get the offenders.


[1] Budiono Darsono, “Online Press”, paper for seminar “Print Media Versus Internet in Information Era”, Jakarta, May 27, 2000.
[2] Detik.com company profile (www.intel.com/apac/eng/eBusiness)
[3] Interview with author on March 12, 2004.
[4] Detik.com company profile (www.intel.com/apac/eng/eBusiness)

[5] Kompas daily, “Media Online Business”, 2003
[6] Sinar Harapan Daily, “The Law for Online Press”, January 22, 2002.

TOO SERIOUS FOR A MALAY

By Akhmad Kusaeni

It is amazing to know how others think and picture our own culture. During my stay in New York (1998-2001), I often met American who has very wrong impression and fatal misconception about Malays people and Malays culture.

“You are too serious for a Malay,” an American friend once told me.

“I thought all Malay are lazy and inefficient, but you are different. You are a hard-working Malay,” another foreign colleague told me another time.

Wait a minute. What make my American friends think so wrong about Malay?

Aha! Some admitted that they have read travel books on Indonesia and listened to tourist-bus anthropologist during short trip to Southeast Asia.

The popular description of Malay in the travel books or the tourist guides are like this: Malays are friendly race of people; always smiling and laughing; people who enjoy an easy life and who are not familiar with hard work. (Goenawan Mohamad, Sidelines, 1994)

Basically, Malays are inefficient people with no spirit of perseverance; creatures who are easily swept away by sudden emotion. Just remember that the English word ‘amok’ is of Malay origin –for the Malays can suddenly draw their kris (a traditional dagger) and start stabbing wildly…

Another English word adopted from Malay language is “sarong”. The sarong is a rectangular piece of cloth about 200 centimeters long, variously patterned, with the two ends of the cloth seamed together to form a cloth ‘tube’. Malays are sarong-wearers.

Americans believe the saying that “You are what you wear”. Since the sarong is considered as an impractical article of clothing, so the sarong-wearers are impractical persons. Am I, as Malay, impractical? Am I too serious for Malay?

No, I am just ordinary Malay. I am friendly to anyone. I like to smile and laugh if there is reason for that. If I always smile and laugh with no reason at all, I must be crazy. As human being and Malay, of course, sometimes I may be emotional. But, I will never do run amok and stabbing wildly other people with my kris. I am not a psychopath. I am not Jack the Ripper.

How to correct misconception?

My three-years in New York opened my eyes that those who live and think in America (the West) are not aware of other cultures, especially minorities such as Malay culture.

As Kishore Mahbubani wrote in The National Interest (1992), the Western mind believes that it understands all the worlds, since it is open to all ideas and closed to none. The paradoxical result of this deep-seated assumption is that the Western mind is actually unaware of the limits of its understanding and comprehension.[1]

I always try to explain to my American friends on how terribly wrong their conception on Malay or Asian culture and correct those mistakes. I always make an attempt to open new windows in their mind by explaining “the truth” about Malays and Malays culture.

I say to them that people only believe what they want to believe. I quote what American philosopher Eric Hoffer [2] says “There is a tendency to judge a race, a nation or any distinct group by its least worthy members”. If the least worthy members of a race are lazy, then the entire race appears lazy. If they are corrupt, then the entire nation is corrupt.

If there are a few that have no love for their native land, then the whole group will be judged accordingly. And if there are some who are unable to work according to the demands of modern life, then people will say, “It’s a matter of mentality, brother”.

I remind them on the perils of generalization. You can’t judge that Malays are lazy people because some of them prefer to enjoy an easy life and who are not familiar with hard work. You can’t judge that Malays are impractical because they wear sarong.

I would say that their (Western) assessment of what is ‘practical’ is not the same as ours (Malays). To us, the sarong is a technological invention precisely right for countless uses. We wear it as part of ceremonial dress, but we also wear it to go to the toilet. We can use it as a type of blanket to ward off the cold, and we can also pull it over our head to keep out of the burning sun.

If we want to run fast we can hitch it up to be like a pair of shorts, by twisting the corners and tying them at the back. We can use the sarong as a mask and when not in use as an article of clothing, the sarong can become at once a wrapper and container for carrying books when we move house. Yes, as Goenawan Mohammad mentioned, it was surely a genius that discovered this article.[3]

After telling what was wrong, I urge my foreign friends to respect Malay and other culture. Sometimes, people have misconception or even prejudices about other culture without realizing that. American take for granted that Malays are lazy people because one of Malay they know is someone who is unable to work according to the demands of modern life.

On the other hand, Indonesian has prejudice about Yankees because some media portray America as a land full of gun-toting, bible-bashing, and collagen-filled lunatics. Japanese was stereotyped as “the economic animal” only because they are hard working people.

If we want to live in peace with other cultures we must respect them to live in harmony with them. We have to get rid of stereotype and prejudice. If there weren’t any respect there would be a clash of civilization. Prejudices based on cultural differences often caused wars. People killed each other only because they looked or acted the other way.

I always remind my American friend that there are a lot of different cultures around the globe. And there are so many things in cultures that other cultures dislike and that usually leads to an argument. What we think in our culture is right isn’t might right in some other culture. That is why we need to learn and understand other cultures.

If we respect other cultures and nations, we don’t have to fight.

If we have understanding with other cultures and nations, there would be no clash of civilization.

If we could understand each other cultures, we would be able to discus worldwide things and problems, for example, the green house effect and pollution.

God bless us with the beautiful rainbow, why we pick only one color? I am interested in different cultures. Like the colorful rainbow, they are fascinating.

REFERENCES

Goenawan Muhammad, Sidelines: Thought Pieces from Tempo Magazine, Lontar, 1994.

Goenawan Muhammad, On Sarongs and other such things, Tempo Magazine, 21 April 1984.

Kishore Mahbubani, The West and the Rest, The National Interest, Number 28, Summer

1992.




[1] Kishore Mahbubani, The West and the Rest, The National Interest, Number 28, Summer 1992.

[2] Goenawan Muhammad, Sidelines, Lontar, 1994.

[3] Goenawan Muhammad, On Sarongs and other such things, Tempo Magazine, 21 April 1984.

ARE MUSLIM NATIONS STINGY?

By Akhmad Kusaeni

Some observers have charged that rich Muslim countries have not done enough to help fellow Muslims affected by the tsunami. The oil-rich states of the Persian Gulf, for example, are doing too little to aid tsunami victims in Aceh, Indonesia.
Indonesia is the world’s most populous Muslim country. It was also the most severely devastated by the wave. Nearly 100,000 of the victims of the December 26 catastrophe were Indonesian Muslims.
But, statistics say we get aid far better from non-Muslims friends than from our Muslim brothers. President George W Bush announced $350 million in the U.S. initial aid, sent the USS Abraham Lincoln into Aceh, including helicopters, and C-130 transport plane. Bush also sent hundreds of tons of pre-packaged emergency aid and supplies, and deployed some 14,000 American troops to help with the recovery and cleanup.
The U.S. helicopters flew at least 30 sorties, delivering 60,000 pounds of water and supplies, from the aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln along a 120-mile stretch of Sumatra Island’s ravaged coastline.
Now, look at what our Muslims brother doing in the midst of calamity. Saudi Arabia and Kuwait, the richest nations in the Islamic world, donated a paltry $10 million each. The United Arab Emirates donated some $20 million to relieve the suffering of their Islamic “brothers”. Qatar has promised to donate $25 million. Bahrain would give $2 million. Egypt’s contribution so far is $104,000.00.
Of disturbing note to me is that most Muslim countries have committed zero aid. Where is the rest of the Islamic world? Where are our brothers in faith? There are fifty-seven Islamic nations, and the world’s biggest Islamic nation is the one that took the hardest hit. But it is the United States –the world’s largest donor nation to tsunami victims in Aceh—that is grabbing all the headlines for being “stingy”.
Who is “stingy” anyway?
The Kuwaiti newspaper “Al Qabas” sparked a firestorm last month when it said the country deserves its reputation for stinginess, in light of the small amount of aid contributed to victims of the tsunami disaster in Asia, especially in Indonesia, a member of Organization of Islamic Conference (OIC).
The newspaper noted that more than half of Kuwait’s labor force is made up of worker from Srilanka, India, Indonesia and other countries affected by the catastrophe. They are largely responsible for the country’s economic success, but the newspaper argued, few Kuwaitis seem to care.
Immediately after the editorial appeared, the government upped its aid contribution to the tsunami relief effort from 2 million dollars to $10 million. But, still, this amount of aid is nothing if we compare with donation comes from non-Muslim Europeans and Americans. Here are the statistics of aid to tsunami victims in Asia.
U.S.A = $350 million
Australia= $764.5 million
Germany= $660 million
Japan= $500 million
Norway= $183 million
Britain= $95 million
Sweden= $75.5 million
Even, private American company like Pfizer donated $10 million in cash and $25 million in drugs. (That is more than oil-rich Saudi Arabia and Kuwait combined). And, Formula One Champion Michael Schumacher donated $10,000,000! How generous our non-Muslim friends are.
On the other hand, where is the jihad against the tsunami from our Muslim brothers? It has been a month now since the earthquake and tsunamis that struck Asia. But still no appropriate actions from OIC and Arab League. Thousands Muslims died in Asia and yet Islamic Development Bank (IDB) is silent. Will the news of mass suffering in Indonesia inspire Islamic world to encourage Muslims to help? I am asking once again: where is the jihad against tsunami?
We have to admit that the United States and European countries are better skilled at communicating with the media and their own citizens, which gives them a higher profile internationally. Like a beauty queen contest, non-Muslim donor countries compete with each other to donate the highest amount of money for tsunami victims.
Of course, there is no such a thing as free lunch. There will always what Indonesian proverb says “Udang di balik batu”. The American government, for instance, has directed its troops and naval forces to Aceh. No doubt, this act of apparent benevolence was likewise colored by genuine political concerns as well.
The Americans know very well that at the moment the image of the U.S. is at an all-time low in Indonesia. The U.S. government tried its best to win over the hearts and minds of the Indonesian Muslims. Washington needs to show that Americans are not anti-Islam and willing to help the victims regardless their religion.
The huge aid effort for tsunami victims in Aceh gives American and European a chance to improve its image as caring and generous friends. Unfortunately, Muslim countries are failed to gain something from tsunami diplomacy.
One of the main criticisms of many Muslim countries is their lack of communication. There is tradition among Muslim people that when they give donation with the right hand, their left hand should not know that noble act. Charity is not something to be shown publicly. Donation is a matter of personal and not to be told to other. Only God knows.
Dr. Farish A. Noor, a Malaysian political scientist and human rights activist, explains another reason why Muslim countries doing “too late and to little” in the wake of tsunami catastrophe. He said, Washington’s “War on Terror” in Southeast Asia has obstructed many Arab and member of OIC donors who find that they cannot donate to Aceh for fear of being accused of funding ‘radical Islamist groups”.
Is that so? Wallahu alam bisawab!

(Akhmad Kusaeni is a graduate student at the Ateneo de Manila University, Phillipines)