By Akhmad Kusaeni
The United States, British and Australian government had warned their citizen against all but essential travel to Indonesia during the Christmas and New Year holidays. The U.S. Department of State, for example, had reminded Americans that the terrorist threat in Indonesia continues and may increase over the December-January holiday period.
The U.S. Intelligence Agency reports indicate that terrorists are planning attacks against a wide variety of targets. These attacks could occur at any time and could be directed against any location, including churches and other religious sites.
Since the “war on terror” was declared after the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks in the U.S., Indonesia has seen three major terror bombings in Jakarta and Bali. For many Indonesians, the days of joyful and peaceful Christmases are long past. Bombings have occurred during the Christmas/New Year's period. At least 15 Christians were killed in the 2000 bombings across the country and 96 other churchgoers were injured.
Fears of bomb attacks also haunt Christmas celebration this time. Police personnel nationwide have pledged that they would beef up security at the churches and cathedrals. The Police bomb squad will comb churches before Christmas sermons were held, and some churches would be equipped with metal detectors.
Every church leader will be tightly guarded by police officers. In addition, police department will also deploy four to 10 officers to guard each church in several provinces. Perhaps no one ever imagined that the citizens of this country would need a police guard to commune with God; yet, this has now become a reality.
Brian Michael Jenkins, expert on terrorism from Rand Corporation, says that a key goal of terrorists is to undermine confidence in our security, our economy and ourselves. According to Jenkins, the most powerful weapon in the terrorist arsenal is fear.
Certainly, the tighter security imposed throughout the country during Christmas and New Year Eve is necessary, but no amount of security can protect us against unbridled fear. We must remember that responding courageously and intellectually to terrorism is far more effective than responding fearfully and emotionally. If we become paranoid because of possible bomb attacks, it mean terrorist arsenal work and terrorism prevail.
Terrorists want us to imprison ourselves. We must not. We should not sit home and hide in basement forever and pray “Oh, Lord, deliver us from evil”. We have to go on with our life. We have Christmas and holiday seasons to celebrate. And nothing can stop us from having a joyful Christmas and a happy New Year. Not, even the travel warnings or traumatic bomb attacks experiences in the past.
Of course, we should not naïve about bombing threats and possibly terrorist attacks. There is no such thing as perfect security in today’s world. That is why all rational precautions need to be taken. We acknowledge that there are still reasons for concerns.
As the main suspects of past bombing cases remain at large, citizen face an extra concern as to whether going to mall for shopping or to church for Christmas Mass will be safe. But, those concerns must not paralyze us. After all, we are dealing with a relatively small number of terrorists. It can be combated and contained without totally shackling ourselves.
In the dark days of the Great Depression, President Frankin Delano Roosevelt said in his 1933 inaugural address: “Let me assert my firm belief that the only thing we have to fear is fear itself --nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror which paralyzes needed efforts to convert retreat into advance.”
Roosevelt was talking about the Great Depression, of course, not the terror spread by Al-Qaeda or Jemaah Islamiyah. But as we dream of the peaceful “White Christmas” Irving Berlin wrote of 62 years ago, we should remember we can come through this “under bomb threats” Christmas if we achieve the freedom from fear Roosevelt called for 70 years ago.
“White Christmas” reflected American people’s deep yearning in the early days of World War II for more peaceful times “just like the one we used to know”. We, Indonesian people, also used to know and to think of Chrismas as a fun-living time to go out, have a big party, open presents.
Bombings threats should not make our Christmas under custody. Don’t let terrorist steal our joyful Christmas celebration and fear of possible terrorist attacks imprison us.
We wish all of our readers a happy and safe holiday.
Jumat, 04 Januari 2008
DON'T LET TERRORIST STEAL OUR JOYFUL CHRISTMAS
CHALLENGES AND WEAKNESSES OF JOURNALISM TODAY
By Akhmad Kusaeni
Journalism’s watchdog role has long been seen as critical to its mission of informing the public. When print periodicals first emerged in England in the 17th century out of the coffeehouse salon culture, they saw their role as investigatory. The Parliament Scout, which began publication in 1643, did more than publish rumors or reprint official words, it made an effort to search out and discover the news.
The Parliament Scout, for the first time, making the affair of government more transparent. Before the journal appeared, the internal workings of government were primarily the knowledge of the privileged-those with business before the state or those directly involved in the administration of government. The general public’s information on their rulers largely came from uninformed gossip. This new periodical told the people what the government actually did. In the process they established investigate reporting as one of the earliest principle of journalism.
“It was the watchdog role that made journalism,” said James Madison. (The History of the Watchdog Mission, Project for Excellence in Journalism, 2003).
Today, a new generation of investigator journalists gave voice to reform at the local, state, federal, regional and international levels. Their detailed investigation and exposure of corrupt power, ranging from child labor abuses to urban political machines and railroad and oil trust, led to a progressive movement in national politics.
But, in the other hand, looking at the global media trend nowadays, investigative journalism is facing new challenges. In my opinion, one of the major challenges (or weaknesses) of journalism today is how easily some are seduced by power. The premier role of the journalist should be as a check on power, however, many seem to turn this dictum on its head and get greater job satisfaction as parrots of the official truth.
The willingness of journalists to accepts the establishment’s view of the events of, and after, 9/11 is truly staggering and disappointing. On war against terrorism, for instance, U.S. media become a megaphone for Bush administration.
But, in Britain, the story is different. The United Kingdom national broadcasters (BBC) could use Iraq war to cultivate its dominant self-image of impartial professionalism and its excellence on investigative reporting. Take the Blair-BBC-Kelly “war” case as an example.
After the war being won by US and Britain coalition forces, Andrew Gilligan of BBC, was trying to investigate the reason for invading Iraq, especially the non-discovery of WMD. He interviewed Dr. David Kelly, a member of the intelligence community, who told Gilligan that “most people in intelligence were dissatisfied with the government’s September dossier on Iraq’s weapon”. David Kelly then committed suicide after his name made public by official in Blair administration.
In the light of the performance of companies like Fox News, which lost its credibility by making itself a tool of Bush administration propaganda, I praise what BBC and Andrew Gilligan has been done. Because the Britain government’s decision to go to war and justification for it deserved the closest possible scrutiny, and a defense correspondence like Gilligan who failed to raise these matters would be failing in his duty. Mr. Gilligan report was a classic example of investigative reporting on a matter of public interest.
How about investigative reporting in Indonesia? There are plenty of cases to be subject of investigative reporting. For example, the riot on May 1998 which lead to the fall of Soeharto, the riot on 27 July 1996 which lead to Chairman of PDIP Party Megawati Soekarnoputri to come to power, corruption that involved Indonesian elites, money politics, illegal logging, etc. But, unfortunately, the media were not giving its reporters to do the job. Most of Indonesian journalists were not brave enough to do investigative reporting because it need hard work and take times.
Only a few media in Indonesia have experienced this special reporting, such as Tempo magazine. But Tommy Winata sued Tempo for publishing its investigative reporting on involvement of this conglomerate to the fire accident of Tanah Abang market. Before the biggest textile market complex in Jakarta set on fire, Tommy Winata has a proposal to rebuild Tanah Abang market. This has made public aware about the possibility that Tanah Abang market was deliberately set on fire in order to rebuild it by Tommy Winata.
Journalism’s watchdog role has long been seen as critical to its mission of informing the public. When print periodicals first emerged in England in the 17th century out of the coffeehouse salon culture, they saw their role as investigatory. The Parliament Scout, which began publication in 1643, did more than publish rumors or reprint official words, it made an effort to search out and discover the news.
The Parliament Scout, for the first time, making the affair of government more transparent. Before the journal appeared, the internal workings of government were primarily the knowledge of the privileged-those with business before the state or those directly involved in the administration of government. The general public’s information on their rulers largely came from uninformed gossip. This new periodical told the people what the government actually did. In the process they established investigate reporting as one of the earliest principle of journalism.
“It was the watchdog role that made journalism,” said James Madison. (The History of the Watchdog Mission, Project for Excellence in Journalism, 2003).
Today, a new generation of investigator journalists gave voice to reform at the local, state, federal, regional and international levels. Their detailed investigation and exposure of corrupt power, ranging from child labor abuses to urban political machines and railroad and oil trust, led to a progressive movement in national politics.
But, in the other hand, looking at the global media trend nowadays, investigative journalism is facing new challenges. In my opinion, one of the major challenges (or weaknesses) of journalism today is how easily some are seduced by power. The premier role of the journalist should be as a check on power, however, many seem to turn this dictum on its head and get greater job satisfaction as parrots of the official truth.
The willingness of journalists to accepts the establishment’s view of the events of, and after, 9/11 is truly staggering and disappointing. On war against terrorism, for instance, U.S. media become a megaphone for Bush administration.
But, in Britain, the story is different. The United Kingdom national broadcasters (BBC) could use Iraq war to cultivate its dominant self-image of impartial professionalism and its excellence on investigative reporting. Take the Blair-BBC-Kelly “war” case as an example.
After the war being won by US and Britain coalition forces, Andrew Gilligan of BBC, was trying to investigate the reason for invading Iraq, especially the non-discovery of WMD. He interviewed Dr. David Kelly, a member of the intelligence community, who told Gilligan that “most people in intelligence were dissatisfied with the government’s September dossier on Iraq’s weapon”. David Kelly then committed suicide after his name made public by official in Blair administration.
In the light of the performance of companies like Fox News, which lost its credibility by making itself a tool of Bush administration propaganda, I praise what BBC and Andrew Gilligan has been done. Because the Britain government’s decision to go to war and justification for it deserved the closest possible scrutiny, and a defense correspondence like Gilligan who failed to raise these matters would be failing in his duty. Mr. Gilligan report was a classic example of investigative reporting on a matter of public interest.
How about investigative reporting in Indonesia? There are plenty of cases to be subject of investigative reporting. For example, the riot on May 1998 which lead to the fall of Soeharto, the riot on 27 July 1996 which lead to Chairman of PDIP Party Megawati Soekarnoputri to come to power, corruption that involved Indonesian elites, money politics, illegal logging, etc. But, unfortunately, the media were not giving its reporters to do the job. Most of Indonesian journalists were not brave enough to do investigative reporting because it need hard work and take times.
Only a few media in Indonesia have experienced this special reporting, such as Tempo magazine. But Tommy Winata sued Tempo for publishing its investigative reporting on involvement of this conglomerate to the fire accident of Tanah Abang market. Before the biggest textile market complex in Jakarta set on fire, Tommy Winata has a proposal to rebuild Tanah Abang market. This has made public aware about the possibility that Tanah Abang market was deliberately set on fire in order to rebuild it by Tommy Winata.
SALAH KAPRAH PENDIDIKAN WARTAWAN
Oleh Akhmad Kusaeni
Jika sekarang ini disebut era informasi, maka lembaga dan perusahaan yang bergerak di bidang komunikasi bagaikan hidup di lumbung padi. Posisi industri media massa di Indonesia saat ini dan yang akan datang merupakan pasar kerja yang bisa menyerap lulusan dari fakultas, institut atau sekolah tinggi pemasok wartawan dan staf bisnis professional yang dibutuhkan industri pers.
Sekarang ini terdapat 566 perusahaan pers media cetak yang menerbitkan koran, majalah dan tabloid. Selain itu terdapat 1.200 radio stasion, 10 stasiun televisi anggota ATVSI ditambah lima televisi daerah. Pokoknya, pasar kerja di bidang komunikasi dan jurnalistik masih terbuka lebar.
Yang jadi masalah adalah sengaja atau tidak pemerintah dan DPR tidak membuat kebijakan tentang siapa yang bertanggungjawab untuk memasok wartawan dan staf bisnis professional bagi kebutuhan industri pers. Undang-Undang Pers No.40/1999 telah memerdekakan pers dari interpensi pemerintah, perizinan, sensor dan ancaman pembredelan. Dampaknya pers media cetak meledak, jumlahnya meningkat dari 289 penerbitan pers pada 1997 menjadi 1.687 pada 1999. Sebagian tidak mampu terbit. Sebagian besar terbit, lalu beberapa waktu kemudian mati.
Menurut Leo Batubara, Ketua Pelaksana Harian Serikat Penerbit Suratkabar (SPS) Pusat, kini tersisa 566. Dari jumlah itu hanya sekitar 30 persen berkatagori professional, sehat dari segi bisnis, beruntung dan berkembang.
Apa penyebab dari 566 perusahaan pers yang beruntung dan berkembang hanya 30 persen? Sebab utama adalah industri pers masih kekurangan SDM professional. Mengapa? Karena ada yang salah dengan sistim di Indonesia. Di negara-negara demokrasi seperti Amerika Serikat, pemasok wartawan professional adalah The Schools of Journalism, sekolah-sekolah tinggi dan institut jurnalistik. Di Indonesia, pemasok terbesar wartawan professional bukanlah Fakultas Komunikasi atau Publisistik. Ironisnya, Institut Pertanian Bogor (IPB) ternyata penyumbang terbesar, sehingga singkatan IPB diplesetkan menjadi Institut Publisistik Bogor.
Masalah pendidikan wartawan memang sudah menjadi wacana dan polemik di Amerika Serikat sejak zaman Pulitzer. Polemik waktu itu dirumuskan dalam pertanyaan, wartawan itu dilahirkan atau dibuat, wartawan itu berdasarkan bakat atau berdasarkan pendidikan. Persoalan serupa timbul di negara-negara lain, termasuk Indonesia.
Dulu, yang jadi wartawan terkemuka di Indonesia umumnya mereka yang memang punya bakat, misalnya BM Diah, Mochtar Lubis, Rosihan Anwar, Mahbub Junaedi. Mereka adalah otodidak, belajar dari pergulatan hidup dan buku-buku yang dibacanya sendiri bukan di bangku kuliah.
Ketika penerbitan pers berkembang dan koran makin banyak, tidak cukup tersedia wartawan yang punya bakat sehingga diperlukan pendidikan khusus untuk wartawan. Pada zaman Pulitzer, meskipun polemik tidak memberi kata putus atas jawaban apakah wartawan itu dilahirkan atau dibuat ( a journalist is to be born or to be made), Pulitzer sendiri memutuskan untuk mendirikan sekolah jurnalistik. Sebab, yang benar adalah sekalipun ada bakat, bakat itu akan berkembang lebih optimal jika diperkaya dan diperdalam oleh pendidikan.
Harus bersaing dengan non-jurnalistik
Maka lahirlah sekolah-sekolah jurnalistik bagai jamur di musim hujan. Hampir setiap Universitas, kini membuka jurusan komunikasi dan jurnalistik. Sehingga kini timbul masalah lain karena para lulusannya harus bersaing dengan lulusan universitas non-jurnalistik yang juga berminat menjadi wartawan. Mereka sarjana dari fakultas teknik, hukum, sosiologi, sastra, biologi dan lain-lain.
Jika lulusan fakultas-fakultas lain menjadi wartawan, dimana tempat bagi mereka yang berasal dari jurusan komunikasi dan perguruan-perguruan tinggi jurnalistik? Penerbit-penerbit kini lebih senang merekrut calon wartawan dari berbagai disiplin ilmu, tidak hanya jurnalistik, karena alasan dibutuhkan wartawan yang spesialis bidang hukum, politik, pertanian dan sebagainya. Sedangkan cara menulis berita, teknik wawancara, dan kode etik bisa dilakukan melalui in house training cukup dua-tiga bulan di penerbitan masing-masing.
Inilah tantangan sekaligus ancaman buat sekolah-sekolah jurnalistik. Supaya sekolah-sekolah jurnalistik ini tetap survive dan lulusannya punya kompetensi di pasar kerja, selain mengembangkan kurikulum yang siap pakai juga diperlukan upaya untuk mendesak agar pemerintah dan DPR merevisi UU Pers yang berlaku. Jika kewartawan itu sebuah profesi maka wartawan mestinya diperlakukan seperti halnya dokter, hakim atau advokat pengacara. Hanya lulusan fakultas kedokteran yang bisa praktek jadi dokter dan sarjana hukum yang bisa jadi pengacara. Sebaiknya, yang bisa menjadi wartawan adalah mereka yang sarjana jurnalistik atau komunikasi lulusan dari The Schools of Journalism.
Jika sekarang ini disebut era informasi, maka lembaga dan perusahaan yang bergerak di bidang komunikasi bagaikan hidup di lumbung padi. Posisi industri media massa di Indonesia saat ini dan yang akan datang merupakan pasar kerja yang bisa menyerap lulusan dari fakultas, institut atau sekolah tinggi pemasok wartawan dan staf bisnis professional yang dibutuhkan industri pers.
Sekarang ini terdapat 566 perusahaan pers media cetak yang menerbitkan koran, majalah dan tabloid. Selain itu terdapat 1.200 radio stasion, 10 stasiun televisi anggota ATVSI ditambah lima televisi daerah. Pokoknya, pasar kerja di bidang komunikasi dan jurnalistik masih terbuka lebar.
Yang jadi masalah adalah sengaja atau tidak pemerintah dan DPR tidak membuat kebijakan tentang siapa yang bertanggungjawab untuk memasok wartawan dan staf bisnis professional bagi kebutuhan industri pers. Undang-Undang Pers No.40/1999 telah memerdekakan pers dari interpensi pemerintah, perizinan, sensor dan ancaman pembredelan. Dampaknya pers media cetak meledak, jumlahnya meningkat dari 289 penerbitan pers pada 1997 menjadi 1.687 pada 1999. Sebagian tidak mampu terbit. Sebagian besar terbit, lalu beberapa waktu kemudian mati.
Menurut Leo Batubara, Ketua Pelaksana Harian Serikat Penerbit Suratkabar (SPS) Pusat, kini tersisa 566. Dari jumlah itu hanya sekitar 30 persen berkatagori professional, sehat dari segi bisnis, beruntung dan berkembang.
Apa penyebab dari 566 perusahaan pers yang beruntung dan berkembang hanya 30 persen? Sebab utama adalah industri pers masih kekurangan SDM professional. Mengapa? Karena ada yang salah dengan sistim di Indonesia. Di negara-negara demokrasi seperti Amerika Serikat, pemasok wartawan professional adalah The Schools of Journalism, sekolah-sekolah tinggi dan institut jurnalistik. Di Indonesia, pemasok terbesar wartawan professional bukanlah Fakultas Komunikasi atau Publisistik. Ironisnya, Institut Pertanian Bogor (IPB) ternyata penyumbang terbesar, sehingga singkatan IPB diplesetkan menjadi Institut Publisistik Bogor.
Masalah pendidikan wartawan memang sudah menjadi wacana dan polemik di Amerika Serikat sejak zaman Pulitzer. Polemik waktu itu dirumuskan dalam pertanyaan, wartawan itu dilahirkan atau dibuat, wartawan itu berdasarkan bakat atau berdasarkan pendidikan. Persoalan serupa timbul di negara-negara lain, termasuk Indonesia.
Dulu, yang jadi wartawan terkemuka di Indonesia umumnya mereka yang memang punya bakat, misalnya BM Diah, Mochtar Lubis, Rosihan Anwar, Mahbub Junaedi. Mereka adalah otodidak, belajar dari pergulatan hidup dan buku-buku yang dibacanya sendiri bukan di bangku kuliah.
Ketika penerbitan pers berkembang dan koran makin banyak, tidak cukup tersedia wartawan yang punya bakat sehingga diperlukan pendidikan khusus untuk wartawan. Pada zaman Pulitzer, meskipun polemik tidak memberi kata putus atas jawaban apakah wartawan itu dilahirkan atau dibuat ( a journalist is to be born or to be made), Pulitzer sendiri memutuskan untuk mendirikan sekolah jurnalistik. Sebab, yang benar adalah sekalipun ada bakat, bakat itu akan berkembang lebih optimal jika diperkaya dan diperdalam oleh pendidikan.
Harus bersaing dengan non-jurnalistik
Maka lahirlah sekolah-sekolah jurnalistik bagai jamur di musim hujan. Hampir setiap Universitas, kini membuka jurusan komunikasi dan jurnalistik. Sehingga kini timbul masalah lain karena para lulusannya harus bersaing dengan lulusan universitas non-jurnalistik yang juga berminat menjadi wartawan. Mereka sarjana dari fakultas teknik, hukum, sosiologi, sastra, biologi dan lain-lain.
Jika lulusan fakultas-fakultas lain menjadi wartawan, dimana tempat bagi mereka yang berasal dari jurusan komunikasi dan perguruan-perguruan tinggi jurnalistik? Penerbit-penerbit kini lebih senang merekrut calon wartawan dari berbagai disiplin ilmu, tidak hanya jurnalistik, karena alasan dibutuhkan wartawan yang spesialis bidang hukum, politik, pertanian dan sebagainya. Sedangkan cara menulis berita, teknik wawancara, dan kode etik bisa dilakukan melalui in house training cukup dua-tiga bulan di penerbitan masing-masing.
Inilah tantangan sekaligus ancaman buat sekolah-sekolah jurnalistik. Supaya sekolah-sekolah jurnalistik ini tetap survive dan lulusannya punya kompetensi di pasar kerja, selain mengembangkan kurikulum yang siap pakai juga diperlukan upaya untuk mendesak agar pemerintah dan DPR merevisi UU Pers yang berlaku. Jika kewartawan itu sebuah profesi maka wartawan mestinya diperlakukan seperti halnya dokter, hakim atau advokat pengacara. Hanya lulusan fakultas kedokteran yang bisa praktek jadi dokter dan sarjana hukum yang bisa jadi pengacara. Sebaiknya, yang bisa menjadi wartawan adalah mereka yang sarjana jurnalistik atau komunikasi lulusan dari The Schools of Journalism.
Langganan:
Postingan (Atom)